71
News:
E-mail address to contact Admin direct is admin@religionethics followed by .co.uk.
Recent Posts
72
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Dicky Underpants on August 26, 2025, 06:15:20 PM »73
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Gordon on August 26, 2025, 06:11:16 PM »I think Gordon, you'll find anyway not to answer the question.
I don't think I need answer a question that, had you understood better, you wouldn't have asked.
74
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Walt Zingmatilder on August 26, 2025, 05:18:59 PM »Your question "Should Historians be able to declare that the resurrection never happened rather than "the resurrection is outside the scope of history" and even the latter sounds odd." indicates that you really don't understand the implications of methodological naturalism, since if you did you wouldn't have asked that particular question.I think Gordon, you'll find anyway not to answer the question.
75
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Maeght on August 26, 2025, 05:13:56 PM »Or didn't. It's not a claim that makes sense in methodological naturalism
Indeed.
76
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Gordon on August 26, 2025, 04:57:01 PM »You don't seem to have answered my question here. Let me guess. Like Gordon you have departmental manager syndrome, being used to ask the questions and being in a position of never having to answer any.
Your question "Should Historians be able to declare that the resurrection never happened rather than "the resurrection is outside the scope of history" and even the latter sounds odd." indicates that you really don't understand the implications of methodological naturalism, since if you did you wouldn't have asked that particular question.
77
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Nearly Sane on August 26, 2025, 04:54:39 PM »You don't seem to have answered my question here. Let me guess. Like Gordon you have departmental manager syndrome, being used to ask the questions and being in a position of never having to answer any.I pointed out why it was both irrelevant and specious.
78
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Nearly Sane on August 26, 2025, 04:53:14 PM »At no point have you said anything about anything.Diddums!
79
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Walt Zingmatilder on August 26, 2025, 04:51:49 PM »At no point have I said that in recognised universities in the UK. it is declared that the resurrection did not happen. You seem to be confused again by the difference between methodological and philosophical naturalism.At no point have you said anything about anything.
80
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Walt Zingmatilder on August 26, 2025, 04:47:45 PM »oh look you have once again elided the study of history and 'history' . At no point have I said that in recognised universities in the UK. it is declared that the resurrection did not happen. You seem to be confused again by the difference between methodological and philosophical naturalism.You don't seem to have answered my question here. Let me guess. Like Gordon you have departmental manager syndrome, being used to ask the questions and being in a position of never having to answer any.