31
Christian Topic / Re: Lewis's Trilemma - split from Matthew topic
« Last post by Walt Zingmatilder on August 28, 2025, 07:26:48 AM »I suspect that the methodological naturalist historian would simply say that the claim (the resurrection of Jesus from being dead) isn't a valid historical question.Hang on, Gordon. A claim is not a question.
The question "Was there a resurrection?" is not invalid as far as I can see and indeed it has been the bread and butter of atheist historians like Bart Ehrman and Richard Carrier for years.
You had me going for a bit but of course, your comment didn't stand up to closer inspection.